Credit Today is the fastest growing publication in the credit field, favored by more and more top credit executives. We cover the world of business, or trade credit, with concise, yet in-depth, reporting. We also publish the most in-depth salary survey in the industry, covering all major credit positions.Credit Today is the fastest growing publication in the credit field, favored by more and more top credit executives. We cover the world of business, or trade credit, with concise, yet in-depth, reporting. We also publish the most in-depth salary survey in the industry, covering all major credit positions.   
Home    Credit Jobs!    Your Account    Search    Resource Directory    Contact    Member Area
 Join Us
We invite you to join our private Members-only Online community and senior level credit executive forum. Click here to learn more.
 Top Resources
Benchmark Central
Best Practices
Checklists
Discussion Forum
Downloads
Job Description-o-matic
 Departments
Bankruptcy Issues
Collections Today
Credit Cards
Credit Dept Profiles
Credit Mgmt Today
Credit Scoring
Deductions Today
Financial Analysis
Fraud
Glossary of Terms
HR Issues Today
International
Legal Issues
Resale Certificates
Resource Directory
Technology Today
Tip of the Week
Unclaimed Property
Outside the Box
Press Releases
 Special Reports
Tech Buyer's Guide
Staff Benchmarking
Salary Survey
Book Store
 About Credit Today
Ad Signup
Media Kit
Mission Statement
Most Popular
Your Account
Member Benefits
Sample Articles
Testimonials
About our ListServ
Forum Signup
Submissions
Tell a Friend
Our Staff
Editorial Advisors
Contact
 Sponsors

Our Subscribers Say...

I think Credit Today is fantastic. You cover many practical topics in the credit field that I use regularly. Just one recent example—a conversation on the ListServ about preferential payments—gave me tips that I used in an actual case. The specific information I picked up from this one discussion saved me $10,000, enough to cover my membership for many years!
- Steve Savino
Manager of Credit & Collections, ASSA Abloy Americas Division, New Haven, CT

Credit Today's Resource Directory and their online e-mail forum (ListServ) provide information on almost any credit-related topic you can think of. It is a great way to exchange information with other credit professionals. As the saying goes, "You don't know what you don't know."
- Scott Goen, Credit Manager, Big Lots Stores, Inc., Wholesale Division

"We've recently started using the ListServ tool within Credit Today. This is phenomenal and powerful forum for gaining immediate feedback, ideas, and suggestions, relative to any credit topic under the sun, all in a real-time e-mail format."
-Javier Vela, Senior Credit Manager, Global Credit Services, JDA Software Group Inc.

"Being a part of the Credit Today online community is like having the expertise of hundreds of credit managers at your fingertips. These credit execs are willing to help you solve topical business issues as they arise. In the current environment of ever increasing competing priorities which reduce our opportunities to meet peers out of the office face-to-face, this is the most valuable tool you can have on your desktop! It's important that we have a mechanism to reach out to our counterparts quickly to exchange knowledge as well as to stay on top of industry trends."
- Victoria Artis, Director of Customer Financial Services, Pfizer, Inc.

"Over the last 10 years I've seen Credit Today evolve from a monthly credit publication into a quality source of information and guidance for the B2B credit community. The website, with its user friendly form downloads, will take you from examples of new account credit applications to bankruptcy forms and everything in between.

The Credit Today ListServ has become the pre-eminent online forum, providing an opportunity for discussion and comments (and occasional humor) from an impressive list of credit professionals."
David Dungan, Director of Credit
Justin Brands, Inc. (A Berkshire Hathaway company)
Fort Worth, Texas

"There are numerous credit periodicals available to the credit professional today. How good is Credit Today? Is it relevant? I always have to read it late, or online because my credit analysts want to read it the minute it comes in. When my staff wants to read a publication before I have a chance to read it then something is working in that publication. We have cancelled our other subscriptions. When you have the best you do not need the rest."
Ron Woods
Corporate Credit Manager-World Wide
Thales Navigation, Inc.

"The newsletter, coupled with the website and the ListServ, are to us, more valuable than any other credit publication, bar none. I try to use at least one article out of each newsletter for departmental training/discussion sessions."
D. Mark Constantine
Corporate Credit Mgr
Fulton Paper Company

"I love Credit Today and read every issue cover to cover. For me, the greatest perk of a subscription is ListServ. I believe Credit Today's ListServ members may be the most knowledgeable Credit brain trust in existence today. I have saved and categorized hundreds of contributions on a wide variety of topics which I refer to often. It's an easy and cost effective way to network and learn."
Doug M. Thomas
Kimberly-Clark Customer Financial Services

Home | Outside the Box | Garnishing An Out-of-State Bank Account? Yes, . . . Search 
Bectran

Garnishing An Out-of-State Bank Account? Yes, It May Be Possible

Bradley D. Blakeley, Esq.
Printer-Friendly Format

The following article appeared in the Winter 2013 issue Blakeley & Blakeley's Trade Creditor's Quarterly

<a href="http://www.bandblaw.com/attorneys.php?attorney=BradleyBlakeley" target="_blank">Bradley Blakeley, Esq.</a> </p>
Judgment creditors often face the issue of whether they can levy on the bank account of an out-of-state judgment debtor. In a common scenario, a judgment creditor, often through its a forum-selection clause in its credit application or contract, obtains a judgment in their home state against an out-of-state judgment debtor. Using the judgment debtor's checks, credit application or perhaps a third-party service, the judgment creditor confirms that the judgment debtor uses a bank with branches in the judgment creditor's home state. Now the question for the judgment creditor is can it levy on the bank in its home state?

The answer can take two forms depending on whether the bank is state chartered or federally chartered. Many years ago, when most banks were state chartered, their funds were held at the branch level. As a result, a judgment creditor's levy had to be branch specific. Specifically, Commercial Code § 4107 provides that "A branch or separate office of a bank is a separate bank for the purpose of computing the time within which and determining the place at or to which action may be taken or notice or orders shall be given under this division and under Division 3 (commencing with Section 3101)."

But in the mid to late 1980s, the banking industry went through major changes, with many banks consolidating or merging. In response, in 1994, Congress passed the Riegle-Neal Interstate Banking and Branching Efficiency Act of 1994 (IBBEA) which was codified to 12 U.S.C. § 1811, which in general was designed to make branch banking more efficient by nationalizing the process for national banks, and regulating state chartered banks that wanted to expand to different host states. As result, national banks went to a state depository framework, with each state having its own depository network, and a levy within the state would capture all accounts in every branch within that State.

In 2004, The Department of the Treasury issued Regulation 12 C.F.R. 7.4007, which authorized national banks to take deposits without regard to state law. Therefore many national banks have created a single depository framework, rather than dividing the accounts into a patchwork of 50 depositories. As part of that process, many banks inserted into its account agreement a provision which allows the bank to maintain a single set of books and to honor levies on a national basis. As been recently explained to me by a national bank, the bank "does not maintain 50 mattresses, one for each state, each with money in it. Rather, it maintains a single mattress for the entire bank."

What if your judgment debtor uses a state chartered bank with locations in different states, including the state where the judgment was entered? While not universally held, courts have determined that a bank does not have physical custody of a depositor's money at a particular site.
start quoteWhile not universally held, courts have determined that a bank does not have physical custody of a depositor's money at a particular siteend quote
Instead, a general deposit into a bank account creates a debt owed by the bank to the depositor. As a result, the judgment creditor can assert that it is the receivable owed by the bank that is being collected, not the actual funds, that provides the basis for recovery.

In the end, we ask do the outcomes described above make common sense? The fact that Congress authorized the Department of the Treasury to allow national banks to do the same is sound in today's national, if not global, economy. Additionally, the principle that the corporation could do business across state lines, but insulate itself from a single levy makes little sense.

Critics may argue that the judgment debtor's account is physically located in its home state where it was opened, and the garnishment should not reach the funds in the account. Those same critics may assert that the judgment creditor should simply domesticate the judgment in the judgment debtor's home state pursuant to full faith and credit, and garnish in that state. In practice, however, in most states the judgment debtor would have notice of the domestication and be afforded an opportunity to move the funds before the garnishment took place. In the end, whether using the theory of a single depository or a bank receivable, judgment creditors and the overburdened legal system are benefited by the ability to garnish against a bank with locations in their home state.

Bradley Blakeley, Esq., earned his bachelors degree from Loyola University, Los Angeles, California, and his law degree from Santa Barbara College of Law (J.D.). Practice areas he specializes in are: commercial law and bankruptcy litigation. He can be reached at bblakeley @ blakeleyllp.com.




Printer-Friendly Format
·  Dispatches From the Credit Front: Battling Banks and 'Incomprehensible Security Documents' in Chapter 11 Proceedings
·  Dispatches From the Credit Front 1-15-12
·  Show Me The Money! Recent Changes to Post-Judgment Collections in North Carolina
·  Dispatches From the Credit Front: August 2012
·  Regarding bankruptcy, does anyone know of a time limit after which they can no longer come after creditors to demand return of preferential payments


Equifax - Forseva
 Most Read
Members only, today...
Members-only, this month...
 Credit Jobs Today
 This Month's Survey

2014 Extended Terms Survey

This month's survey takes a look at:
  • The extent to which customers are demanding longer terms ("their" payment terms, rather than your selling terms)
  • Who approves any requests for longer terms
  • Whether companies have formal policies in place to handle such requests
  • How far terms are being extended
  • What strategies are used by companies when these requests are received
  • Whether credit managers' own companies are also seeking longer terms from THEIR suppliers (and what we can learn from that)
If you're as interested in these results as we are, then please click here to participate!

 Credit Calendar
Previous Month October 2014 Next Month
S M T W T F S
      1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30 31